Panoramas

Decks and kinds · 3 min read

Tarot de Marseille vs. Rider-Waite-Smith: how they differ

The Tarot de Marseille and the Rider-Waite-Smith are the two best-known patterns, and they are more alike than they look. Here are the real differences: history, who painted each, and why Justice and Strength trade numbers.

One family, two eras

Both decks have 78 cards, with 22 major arcana and 56 minors in four suits. Centuries separate them, and so does the way they treat images: the Marseille deck comes out of the tradition of playing-card decks, while the Rider-Waite-Smith (RWS) was designed in the 20th century with symbolic reading in mind.

The Tarot de Marseille

It is a pattern rather than a single deck: a design that many printers repeated with variations. It became popular in France in the 17th and 18th centuries, mostly as a deck for playing games. The name "de Marseille" is much later; Romain Merlin coined it in 1856.

The oldest known deck of this pattern was made by Philippe Vachier in Marseille in 1639. Among the best known are Noblet's, around 1650, and Nicolas Conver's, around 1760. Conver's caught the eye of Court de Gébelin and became the model for much of the occult tarot that followed.

Its minor cards from ace to ten have no scenes: just the right number of batons, cups, swords or coins, arranged in a spare, graphic design.

The Rider-Waite-Smith and Pamela Colman Smith

William Rider & Son of London published the RWS at the end of 1909. Arthur Edward Waite directed it and Pamela Colman Smith illustrated it. Both belonged to the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn. In 1910 Waite published a companion book, The Pictorial Key to the Tarot.

Smith was born in London in 1878, grew up in Manchester and, from 1889, in Jamaica. She studied at the Pratt Institute in Brooklyn and worked with Ellen Terry's Lyceum Theatre circle. Waite commissioned the deck in 1909, and she drew it between April and October of that year. She died in 1951.

According to the Victoria and Albert Museum, Waite gave detailed instructions for the major arcana, while Smith had a free hand with the minors. That is why many people now call it the Waite-Smith deck. The first editions were labeled simply "Tarot Cards," with no author in the title, and Smith's name is now added to Waite's and the publisher's.

The minors: without scenes and with scenes

The most visible difference is in the 56 minors. In Marseille, a three of cups shows three cups and little else. In the RWS, every number has a scene with figures, which you can read almost like a small story.

Some scholars think Smith drew on the 15th-century Sola Busca tarot for those scenes, but the link is unconfirmed, and sources contradict each other on how she might have seen it. What is clear is that before the RWS, with a few rare exceptions, the minors had plain designs.

Justice and Strength: VIII and XI

In Marseille decks, Justice is VIII and Strength is XI. An early example is the Lyon printer Jean Dodal's deck of 1715. In the RWS the numbers are swapped: Strength is VIII and Justice is XI.

No new cards appeared; they are the same two cards in a different order. The swap comes from the Golden Dawn tradition, which paired each card with a zodiac sign and wanted Strength to match Leo and Justice to match Libra. Waite explains it in his book: "For reasons which satisfy myself, this card has been interchanged with that of Justice, which is usually numbered eight."

Sources disagree on who made the change first, the Golden Dawn itself or Waite. Both numberings are in use today; many English-language decks follow the RWS.

Which to choose, and what this deck follows

Neither is the correct one. If you like reading scenes, the RWS gives you more to look at. If you prefer the austerity of the older design, Marseille leaves more room for what you see yourself.

This deck follows the Marseille order, with Justice at VIII, Strength at XI and the Fool as 0. In the Rider-Waite-Smith sequence those two numbers are swapped, and the difference is one of order only. Its 56 minors follow neither the Marseille nor the Waite model: they are named archetypes, as explained in the article on major and minor arcana.

Common questions

What is the difference between Tarot de Marseille and Rider-Waite?

Marseille is a 17th- and 18th-century playing-deck pattern whose minor cards have no scenes. The Rider-Waite-Smith was published in 1909 and has a scene on every minor card. The numbering of Justice and Strength also differs.

Who painted the Rider-Waite tarot?

Pamela Colman Smith, under the direction of A. E. Waite. William Rider & Son of London published it at the end of 1909.

Why do Strength and Justice swap numbers?

In Marseille, Justice is VIII and Strength is XI. In the Rider-Waite they are swapped, following the Golden Dawn's astrological correspondences (Leo and Libra). Waite wrote that he did it "for reasons which satisfy myself."

Which numbering does this deck use?

Marseille's: Justice is VIII and Strength is XI. They are the same cards as in the Rider-Waite-Smith, only in a different order.

Sources

Do a reading

Keep reading