Panoramas

Symbols and archetypes · 4 min read

The four elements and the suits

In many books, wands are fire, cups are water, swords are air and coins are earth. That pairing is fairly recent and comes from one particular tradition; here is where it comes from and what becomes of it in this deck.

Where the four elements come from

The idea of four elements is far older than tarot. The Greek philosopher Empedocles, born in the early fifth century BCE, held that everything is made of four "roots": air, water, earth and fire. Later, around 350 BCE, Aristotle linked each with two of four qualities: fire is hot and dry, air hot and wet, water cold and wet, earth cold and dry. That theory passed into medieval medicine and alchemy, and only in the 17th century did it begin to be tested by experiment; Robert Boyle's The Sceptical Chymist (1661) challenged it.

Tarot did not grow out of that idea. The first decks were a card game, and the sources consulted do not mention elements in them.

The suits before the elements

The four suits of classic tarot come from Italian playing cards: batons, cups, swords and coins, which some decks call pentacles. In the Tarot de Marseille the cards from ace to ten show only the number of suit symbols, with no scenes.

In those Marseille decks the swords are drawn as curved lines and the batons as straight lines crossing in a lattice.

In his 1910 book, Waite names them as wands or scepters, cups, swords and pentacles, which he also calls deniers or money, and compares them with the suits of modern playing cards.

What the Golden Dawn did

The pairing of each suit with an element that is taught today comes mostly from the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, an initiatory society founded in late 19th-century England. Its system, as researcher Mary K. Greer records it, runs like this:

Wands go with fire, in Atziluth, the archetypal world. Cups go with water, in Briah, the creative one. Swords go with air, in Yetzirah, the formative one. Coins or pentacles go with earth, in Assiah, the material one. Those four worlds come from the Kabbalah, which describes how the "Breath of God" descends from spirit into matter.

The order also gave elements to some majors. In its table of correspondences the Fool is air, the Hanged Man is water and Judgement is fire. Those three cards are tied to the Hebrew letters Aleph, Mem and Shin.

The central document with those interpretations, known as Book T, was first published openly, though not under that title, in 1912 in Aleister Crowley's periodical The Equinox. Until then it was internal material of the order.

What Waite wrote

Waite was a member of the Golden Dawn, and elements show up in his book. He describes the Magician's table, where the symbols of the four suits lie, and says they signify "the elements of natural life"; the Magician arranges them "as he wills."

But Waite also parted from part of the system. He wrote that he did not adopt the attribution of the majors to the Hebrew alphabet, because "nearly every attribution is wrong." Those Hebrew letters are the ones the order used to give air to the Fool, water to the Hanged Man and fire to Judgement.

A convention, not a fact

These pairings are conventions of one order, formed in 1887 and housed in its first London temple from 1888, and of the authors who followed it. They are not a fact about the cards or the world. A deck can be read with them or without them. That is why this library treats them as one reading option, not as the meaning of a suit.

Even within one tradition the schemes can vary. The Golden Dawn itself had more than one color scale for the elements, and in one air is yellow while in another it is greenish blue, as the article on colors in tarot shows.

So when a book says "swords are air," the accurate reading is "in the Golden Dawn tradition, swords go with air."

And in this deck

This deck has no suits. Its 56 minors are individual archetypes with names of their own, such as the fog or the harvest, grouped into seven sets of eight only to make them easy to find. There are no wands, cups, swords or coins, and so no match with the elements.

No card in this deck is assigned fire, water, air or earth. Each card is read by its name, its image and the place it holds in the spread.

In the twelve-houses spread the majors set the theme of each house and the minors refine it, one on each side. No element enters into that arrangement: the house and the position give the order.

If you also read with another deck that has suits, you can use the elements as one more lens, knowing which tradition they come from. Here they are not needed.

Common questions

Which element is each tarot suit?

In the Golden Dawn tradition: wands are fire, cups are water, swords are air and coins or pentacles are earth. It is a convention of that order, not a fact about the cards.

Are the elements part of the original tarot?

No. The suits come from Italian playing cards. The pairing with the elements that is taught today comes mostly from the Golden Dawn, an order of the late 19th century.

Does this tarot use the four elements?

No. This deck has no suits, and its 56 minors are archetypes with names of their own. No card has an element assigned.

Do I need to know the elements to read tarot?

No. It is one tradition among others. A card can be read by its image, its name and the place it holds in the spread.

Sources

Do a reading

Keep reading